Guardian reports a CPS prosecutor relied on a nonexistent case that came from an AI search summary
The Guardian · Reporting
Read the source (opens in a new tab)- What happened
- The Guardian reported on November 3, 2026 that a senior Crown Prosecution Service lawyer relied on a nonexistent case, R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529, to argue for continuing a youth court prosecution.
- Key points
- The Guardian says it "understands the reference came from an AI response generated during an internet search"; two High Court judges called the prosecutor's explanation "unsatisfactory."
- The High Court said the fictitious case did not affect the outcome of the defendant's challenge to the decision to continue the prosecution.
- The CPS said it "identified an error had occurred from conducting legal research using the internet," reviewed other cases, and that its AI policy requires "human checks for accuracy."
- It is the second known CPS case after one in February; a UK tracker kept by barrister Matthew Lee now lists 101 entries of confirmed, suspected and disputed AI-related errors and false citations.
- Evidence
- Newspaper exclusive by Robert Booth, based on high court documents. The AI link rests on what the Guardian says it understands.
- Uncertain
- The Guardian does not say how it learned of the AI summary, and the CPS's explanation of the error refers to internet research, not AI.