Guardian reports a CPS prosecutor relied on a nonexistent case that came from an AI search summary

The Guardian · Reporting

Read the source (opens in a new tab)
What happened
The Guardian reported on November 3, 2026 that a senior Crown Prosecution Service lawyer relied on a nonexistent case, R v J [2024] EWCA Crim 3529, to argue for continuing a youth court prosecution.
Key points
  • The Guardian says it "understands the reference came from an AI response generated during an internet search"; two High Court judges called the prosecutor's explanation "unsatisfactory."
  • The High Court said the fictitious case did not affect the outcome of the defendant's challenge to the decision to continue the prosecution.
  • The CPS said it "identified an error had occurred from conducting legal research using the internet," reviewed other cases, and that its AI policy requires "human checks for accuracy."
  • It is the second known CPS case after one in February; a UK tracker kept by barrister Matthew Lee now lists 101 entries of confirmed, suspected and disputed AI-related errors and false citations.
Evidence
Newspaper exclusive by Robert Booth, based on high court documents. The AI link rests on what the Guardian says it understands.
Uncertain
The Guardian does not say how it learned of the AI summary, and the CPS's explanation of the error refers to internet research, not AI.

See it in the latest record