RAND-led study finds four chatbots cover adolescent depression less fully than anxiety, and severe cases less than moderate

Nature Mental Health · Research paper

Read the source (opens in a new tab)
What happened
A RAND-led team published a study in Nature Mental Health on October 28, 2026 presenting a clinician-informed tool to score chatbot replies to adolescents disclosing anxiety or depression.
Key points
  • The Adolescent Mental Health AI Response Tool checks replies for guideline-informed content across seven domains; clinicians reviewed its items for evidence base and clinical importance.
  • A three-model AI evaluator scored multiturn conversations between ChatGPT-5, ChatGPT-4, Claude 4.5 and Gemini 2.5 and adolescent personas varying by sex, diagnosis and severity.
  • Replies covered more of the applicable criteria for anxiety than for depression, and for moderate than for severe presentations; the authors also report gaps in coping guidance.
Evidence
Peer-reviewed study of simulated conversations with adolescent personas, not real users. It measures whether replies contain guideline content, not how replies affect young people.

See it in the latest record