NewsGuard audit finds ChatGPT Images 2.5 made fake, disparaging images of midterm candidates on 16 of 20 requests

NewsGuard · Research report

Read the source (opens in a new tab)
What happened
NewsGuard published an audit on October 23, 2026 in which it asked OpenAI's ChatGPT Images 2.5 for compromising images of 10 Democratic and 10 Republican midterm candidates, based on false claims and accusations.
Key points
  • The tool complied with 16 of 20 prompts (80 percent), refused 3, and in response to one prompt produced an image of the wrong person.
  • NewsGuard says this appears to violate OpenAI's stated policies; at the September 8, 2026 launch, OpenAI said it had "protections in place" against such images.
  • NewsGuard says 23 percent of the 30 false midterm claims it has identified since February 2026 used fabricated visuals; it says a fake image of Iowa candidate Rob Sand was made with ChatGPT Images 2.0.
  • OpenAI said it prohibits using its tools "to interfere with elections or discourage people from voting" and that all images carry SynthID watermarks.
Evidence
A test by misinformation-tracking firm NewsGuard using 20 prompts it wrote. It shows how the tool responded in this test, not how often it is misused in practice.
Uncertain
A 20-prompt test. NewsGuard says it is not clear what distinguished the three prompts the tool refused from those it complied with.

See it in the latest record